Mar 9, 2018
This is the second in our new series of things we didn’t know about certain colleges--or about higher education generally. I think this is a case of the more you learn, the more you realize you don’t know. Even though we have worked with colleges for a living for decades, we have learned a lot doing our 150-plus episodes, and we hope you have, too.
Today’s episode focuses on something that I did not know existed: instant college admission decisions, which sound like a great stress-reliever to me. Because who wants to apply to a college on January 1 and wait three months to get an answer! So, while many students solve that waiting problem by applying under Early Action or Early Decision plans, thus shortening their wait time to perhaps six weeks or so in November and December, other students are taking advantage of instant decisions. Here’s the story, thanks to Kelly Mae Ross and her article last December for U.S. News & World Report.
So, what are instant decision days? They are exactly what they sound like. They are events held at high schools or colleges for prospective freshmen, staffed by a college’s admission officer, who interviews prospective students for a short period of time (as little as 15 minutes) and provides an admission decision on the spot.
The interview allows a prospective student to explain little glitches in his or her academic record as well as to elaborate on personal and academic accomplishments. It also gives a prospective student a chance to ask questions about the college. Because the interview is so short, students need not be too nervous. And because the interview is quick and somewhat informal, students need not go overboard dressing up. According to Ms. Ross’s article, Kasey Urquidez, vice president of enrollment management and student affairs advancement and dean of undergraduate admissions at the University of Arizona, commented, “I can say for our team, [student dress is] not something we’re looking at whatsoever. So dress as a student--it’s what we expect.” (quoted from the article)
(Of course, I am going to add here that students should not dress like slobs, either. I can live with “business casual” attire--just short of a tie and jacket for young men, for example. Furthermore, students should remember that a speedy, seemingly informal event still requires that standard formal slang-free English be spoken.)
While financial aid packages might not be provided on the spot at the time of the instant decision, a newly accepted student can at least get advice on what to do next to secure financial assistance.
And here’s a plus: Some colleges will waive the application fee for instant decision applicants. So, that could save you a few bucks, which never hurts.
And here’s another plus: When these instant decision events are held on the college campus rather than at your kid’s high school, some colleges offer students a campus tour and the chance to meet current students--all accomplished in one jam-packed day.
And here’s perhaps the biggest plus: Instant admission decisions are not binding. That means, of course, that a student can continue to apply to other colleges or continue to wait to hear from other colleges before making an enrollment decision.
Not surprisingly, some colleges require that a prospective student complete the application in advance (which seems reasonable). Some colleges have minimum academic standards that prospective students must meet in order to participate in an instant decision event (which seems reasonable, too). And some colleges permit instant decisions for just some, but not all, of their degree programs (which also seems okay to me).
But the bottom line is this: There is just no downside to taking part in one of these instant decision days if a college your kid is interested in makes one available.
So, what colleges have them? It’s not surprising that highly selective colleges do not offer instant decision events. But Ms. Ross’s article spotlights one that does: Millersville University of Pennsylvania. With 7,000 undergraduate students, Millersville is a public university located in rural Lancaster County, in the heart of Amish country, though not too far a drive from Philadelphia. Founded as a teacher’s college in 1855, Millersville now offers more than 100 undergraduate programs of study. Out-of-state tuition is about $22,000 per year—rather reasonable, when compared to private colleges. Admissions standards are also quite reasonable, given its public mission as part of the 14-campus system of Pennsylvania’s State System of Higher Education (which is a separate state system from the more selective Pennsylvania State University (of football fame) system). The Millersville freshman class profile shows an average SAT of 1050, an average ACT composite of 22, and a high school GPA average of 3.4. And, according to its own Fast Facts on its website, 95 percent of graduates are employed within six months.
While the freshman class profile statistics indicate that Millersville is not a highly selective institution, having a positive instant admission decision in a student’s pocket from a solid public university is not a bad way to relieve the stress of the college application process. And, in her article, Ms. Ross quotes Brian Hazlett, vice president for student affairs and enrollment management at Millersville, as saying that students who do not get an acceptance on instant decision day can get advice on how to make their application better. It’s like personal counseling for free!
Ms. Ross’s article continues:
“It’s a very, very personal way of going through the admissions process,” says John Iacovelli, dean of enrollment management at Stockton University in New Jersey, which holds about three dozen instant decision events at high schools each year. (quoted from the article)
Stockton University, by the way, is a public university in southern New Jersey, opened in 1971, which enrolls over 9,000 undergraduate and graduate students, about 1,500 of whom are first-time freshmen. After six months, 88 percent of its graduates are employed or enrolled in graduate school. Both this 88 percent and Millersville’s 95 percent strike me as very good statistics for any university, but perhaps especially so for a public university.
In case you have a kid already in college and looking to transfer, it might be worth noting that some colleges have these instant decision days for transfer students, too. Ms. Ross offers this information in her article:
Some university admissions officers travel to community colleges to offer this opportunity to prospective transfer students.
The University of Arizona offers about a dozen such events each year, says Kasey Urquidez, vice president enrollment management and student affairs advancement, and dean of undergraduate admissions at the university.
Virginia Tech…hosts instant decision days at four nearby community colleges, says Jane Todd, the school’s associate director for transfer initiatives….
Prospective transfer students should register in advance, submit their application and obtain a copy of their transcript before meeting with the admissions officer, both Todd and Urquidez say. Students who have attended multiple colleges will need a transcript from each, says Urquidez, and collecting all of these documents can take time. (quoted from the article)
Well, the University of Arizona and Virginia Tech! These are gigantic public universities that are well respected in their states (and nationally, too) and very likely by the nearby community college students who could take advantage of these instant decision days. Given our nation’s scandalously low rates of community college students transferring to four-year institutions to continue their educations, these instant decision days have to be a step--or a giant leap--in the right direction.
So, what should you do with this information? Well, if I were you, I would start looking for colleges that offer the instant decision events, either on their campus or at your kid’s high school. Ask the guidance counselor about any such events at the high school. If there aren’t any scheduled, suggest that the guidance counselor look into this option, perhaps especially from nearby public two-year and four-year colleges.
In my search for information, I ran across a posting on the website for Saratoga Springs High School, located in the beautiful upstate town of Saratoga Springs, New York. The notice explained that eight colleges would be conducting “instant decision” and “instant admit” sessions at the high school between October 30 and December 15. The colleges were both public and private, both two-year and four-year, and both large and small, including one major campus of the State University of New York system. That’s not a bad deal for those seniors, especially those who did not have their hearts set on highly selective colleges or those who needed or wanted to attend a nearby public institution.
What’s the bottom line? It is that it never hurts to have a little stress relieved by these instant decision days. There are few things in education that have no downside, as we have said in the past. One of those things we have talked about often is student internships during high school. Another of those things is Early College high schools and other college-credit-in-high-school programs. Another of those things is Early Action admission plans. There is just no downside to any one of these things. And now we will add instant decision days. Just no downside. So, do a little research in your own community and happy hunting!