We had the opportunity to talk with about 100 high school
seniors from a very good high school in New York City a couple of
weeks ago. Each student had written down three ideas for a common
application essay, and we told each student which one (or two) we
thought were worth developing.
Last weekend, I read all of the essays they had written, and I
went back to the school to go over them with the students. Here is
what I told the classes (in brief):
- Pay attention to your grammar—Watch out for basic punctuation
mistakes (no comma before the “and” in a compound sentence, periods
and commas outside quotation marks, incorrect use of semicolons and
dashes, lack of hyphenation in compound adjectives before nouns),
missing grammatical “niceties” (no split infinitives, correct
placement of “only” in a sentence), and incorrect verb tenses
(inexplicable shifts from present to past tense or vice
versa, lack of appropriate use of the past perfect
- Be careful about your word choice—Don’t use a sophisticated or
“big” word that you would never use naturally in your own formal
speech (like when you are talking in class or to a teacher). It
almost never works, and you often use the word just slightly
- Get rid of wordiness—Do not use 15 words to say what 5 words
could have said just as well, if not better, and omit unnecessary
qualifiers that weaken your writing (e.g., somewhat, a bit, very).
Keep your writing crisp and clear; make it flow. For the main essay
in the Common App, you have a word limit of 650 words, which is not
really a lot. Don’t waste them. But, for sure, don’t write 650
words if you have only 550 words’ worth to say. Just leave it at
- Grab the reader’s attention twice—Write a great first sentence,
which makes the admissions officer want to continue reading your
essay (when he or she has hundreds more to read). Then, write a
great final sentence, which is your last chance to make an
impression on that admissions officer.
- Remember what the point is—If you are telling a story as part
of your essay, the story is not the point; the point is the point.
In other words, what you learned from the experience you are
writing about or how the experience impacted your choice of a field
to study in college or a career or how the experience changed your
thinking is the point of the essay. The story is a means to an end;
the point is the end. And don’t get bogged down in the details of
your story; the reader doesn’t need to know every single thing that
happened. Be selective or summarize to keep the story moving.
The long-time and accomplished English teacher we were working
with told her students that it was important not to distract the
reader with grammatical mistakes and wordiness and poor word
choice. She explained that all of those things would make the
reader stop for a second and look puzzled. She is right.
Breaking your reader’s engagement with you and your essay
because of mistakes you shouldn’t be making as a high school senior
could mean all the difference. Ask an adult for help. It is
super-hard to edit your own essay and catch all of your mistakes.
Get someone to talk it through with you, and don’t wait until the
last minute to do it.
Listen to the podcast to find out about…
- Some great opening lines
- Some college websites that might help you
- Some adults who might help you
Ask your questions or share your feedback by…
- Leaving a comment on the show notes for this episode at
- Calling us at (516) 900-NYCC to record a question on our
NYCollegeChat voicemail if you want us to answer your question live
on our podcast
- Emailing us at firstname.lastname@example.org to ask a
question if you want us to answer it privately
Connect with us through…